My brother, why do you deny the Prophetic Sunnah?
What is my need for it? Why would I need probabilistic books when I have a definitive Book (the Quran)?
But the Prophetic Sunnah completes the religion.
Allah says: (This day I have perfected for you your religion and completed My favor upon you and have approved for you Islam as religion [5:3]). Only that which is incomplete needs completion; is the Quran incomplete?
No, but the Prophetic Sunnah is what explained and interpreted the Quran for us!
Interesting. Where is this interpretation? Where are the Hadiths that explained Surah Al-Baqarah or Al-Imran, for example?
Where are the Prophetic Hadiths that explained the disjointed letters at the beginning of the chapters like (Alif-Lam-Mim, Ha-Mim, Kaf-Ha-Ya-'Ayn-Sad... etc.)? Where are they?
Does there exist a tafsir (interpretation) of the Quran titled "The Prophet's Interpretation," alongside the dozens of interpretations like those of Ibn Kathir, Al-Qurtubi, Al-Sa'di, and others?
If the Prophetic Sunnah is the explainer and detailer of the Quran, as you and our "noble jurists" claim, then you face a huge problem: you must provide us with Prophetic Hadiths that explained the entire Quran. If you cannot, then you are essentially accusing the Prophet of not fulfilling his duty perfectly by leaving the Quran without interpretation, or your claim is simply incorrect and the Sunnah is not the primary interpreter of the Quran.
Choose whichever suits you.
You infidel! You heretic! You will all die, and the Sunnah will remain because lions protect it.
Yes, we will all die. Death is not a divine revenge; all Prophets, the righteous, and the wicked have died. Death is a law of the universe.
But there is a difference between one who meets Allah with a sound heart, holding fast to His Book, and one who meets Him with a heart saturated with human-made books that he made the judge over the Quran, thinking he is doing good.
The Quran doesn't need lions, tigers, leopards, or even monkeys to defend it. The strong does not need anyone to strengthen it.
Only the weak, the frail, and the crumbling need defense to keep from falling.
The reason for the survival of what you falsely call "The Second Revelation" is not because of its strength or status, but because of the clerical dominance defending it—which since the early era has been sitting on the necks of Muslims, harming and killing anyone who criticizes it.
This is how they are: they start with "my brother" and end with "infidel."
You recognize them, right?